Frustrated by Phthalates

I wanted to coat dried leaves with mod podge (originally from here I guess) to play with my daughter, because it sounded like lots of fun – it makes the leaves soft again. But there, that makes the leaves soft again – but glues are often plastics, and that sounds like plastic softeners, doesn’t it? Which sounds like phthalates (phthalates are plastic softeners). So I try to figure it out, and it seems by looking at the patent (3,616,005 – listed on the bottle) that Mod Podge likely has dibutyl phthalate in it as the softener. (In addition to the MSDS (material safety data sheet) listing vinyl acetate which is somewhat carcinogenic.)

And yet, it has the “AP nontoxic” seal on it, because all nontoxic means is unlikely to cause problems if used according to label. It does NOT mean it is okay if your kids eat it. The MSDS sheet even says: “INGESTION: Not an anticipated route of exposure. Small amounts are not anticipated to be harmful.” Comforting.

So now I’m trying to figure out what exactly is in the other kinds of white glue. Seems white glue is usually some form of polyvinyl acetate. Which Wikipedia says cross-links in the presence of boron compounds like borax, to make gak. I’m learning things today. There may be other chemicals that borax makes crosslink to form gak, but all my gak forming white washable school glue is probably mainly polyvinyl acetate, and it probably all has di-butyl phthalate in it, because that is the cheap way to do things.

I hate our synthetic chemical world. (Not that there aren’t plenty of natural poisons, like many houseplants our kiddies could be eating.)

But now I’ll go try to get over my panic attack and go to bed…

4 Comments

Add Yours →

So frustrating. I never would have thought to look up the patent.

I try to reassure myself by thinking of all the hazardous things I played with as a child. And apparently when my dad was a kid the big “must-have” item was a watch that glowed – because it was radioactive.

My grandfather was a chemist, and all his kids played with mercury and other things. None of the ‘nontoxic’ stuff is going to acutely hurt you, it’s just the elevation of risk with all of the other environmental pollutants, right? So we do what we can.

This post made me laugh (better than crying, right?), because it reminded me so much of myself. I try to find the “safest” plastics I can when we need to buy them — I never would have thought about plastic softeners in modge podge, though I haven’t used it with my son. My son also has an allergy to wheat, dairy, nuts, eggs, and sesame (those things appear in playdough, paste, lots of soaps and shampoos). You can just imagine the way I scrutinize things I want to purchase! Can you imagine life before the google? 😉

Leave a Reply